Early Learning Made Easy · Making Early Learning Simple, Joyful, and Evidence-Based

Inclusive Thanksgiving: Celebrating Gratitude Without the Pilgrim Story

By Ms. Vanessa · Early Learning Made Easy

Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains Amazon affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases—at no extra cost to you. I only recommend items that align with early childhood best practices.

Free today for subscribers: Get the printable “Gratitude Circle” group activity guide delivered to your inbox. Not subscribed yet? Click here to subscribe for free (today only for this resource).

Subscribe Free · Get Today’s Freebie Buy Article + Gratitude Circle Premium Members: Sign In

Premium Members enjoy instant, unlimited access to all ELME articles & resources free in the Gumroad library.

Why an Inclusive Approach Matters

Many preschool Thanksgiving traditions rely on simplified stories about Pilgrims and Native Peoples that can unintentionally reinforce stereotypes. We can keep the heart of the season—gratitude, generosity, and community—without costumes or myths. A harvest-themed approach honors all children and families while staying developmentally appropriate and culturally respectful.

Research-Informed Foundations

Programs thrive when classrooms are culturally responsive, emphasize belonging, and center social–emotional learning. Gratitude practices strengthen children’s sense of connection, empathy, and well-being—and inclusive language models respect for diverse family traditions.

Do This / Avoid This

• Do focus on universal themes: gratitude, sharing, family meals, fall harvest, and helping others.
• Do use classroom-safe language: “fall celebration,” “gratitude circle,” “sharing feast,” “harvest tasting.”
• Do invite family voices with prompts like, “In our home, we say thank you by…,” without requiring a specific holiday story.
• Do check food safety and inclusion (allergies, cultural dietary needs) and provide opt-ins for sensory needs.
• Avoid costumes or crafts that imitate cultural regalia.
• Avoid reenactments of historical events or simplified “Pilgrim and Indian” narratives.
• Avoid asking one child to “represent” a culture or implying one “right” way to celebrate.

Classroom-Safe Language Swaps

• “Pilgrim feast” → “classroom harvest celebration”
• “Indian headdress craft” → “leaf crown” or “autumn headband”
• “First Thanksgiving story” → “Noticing our harvest: colors, smells, tastes, and thanks”
• “What Pilgrims ate” → “What foods do we enjoy with our families?”

Inclusive, Harvest-Themed Activity Ideas (Ages 2–5)

• Color Hunt: find items in harvest colors (red, orange, yellow, brown, green).
• Gratitude Collage: glue pictures of people/places you love (family photos optional).
• Harvest Tasting: sample safe foods like apple slices or roasted pumpkin seeds (check allergies).
• Kindness Kitchen: pretend-play with recipe cards about sharing and helping.
• Thank-You Postcards: draw/dictate a note to a helper (custodian, bus driver, lunch staff).
• Music & Movement: “fall breeze” scarf dancing; “crunchy leaves” stomping game.

Helpful Books & Tools

Gratitude is My Superpower

by Alicia Ortego

Decoration Set: Pumpkin Spice & Everything Nice

Feelings Posters & SEL Visuals

Conversation Cards for Kids

Want the printable “Gratitude Circle” guide? It’s included with today’s subscriber email. Subscribe free here. Prefer to own a copy without subscribing? Purchase the Article + Guide on Gumroad. Premium Members already have instant access to everything: Join Premium.

Related Post: Gratitude Grows, Teaching Thankfulness in Early Childhood

Independently created by Early Learning Made Easy and informed by best practices in culturally responsive early childhood education. Not affiliated with or endorsed by any external institution or author.

Early Learning Made Easy — Making Early Learning Simple, Joyful, and Evidence-Based.

Subscribe Free · Shop the Gumroad Store · Premium Membership

✨ You’re Doing Amazing — Let’s Make Learning Simple ✨

Subscribe to my blog for instant access to today’s Featured Freebie — plus weekly printables, early learning tips, and new resource alerts.

✉️ Subscribe for Instant Access

---

Want unlimited access to every premium resource and future freebie — forever?

⭐ Become a Premium Member

(One-time purchase. Lifetime access.)

🛍️ Shop All Resources

Already a member? Request your freebie here

No spam — just real tools that make early learning simple, joyful, and evidence-based.

About Early Learning Made Easy:
Created by Ms. Vanessa, CDA-certified Early Childhood Educator. This blog provides simple, joyful, evidence-informed learning activities for families and caregivers.

Affiliate & Research Disclosure:
This site may include Amazon affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you. Content is independently created and informed by evidence-based research.

© Early Learning Made Easy — All Rights Reserved.